Blame It On ObamaCare

26 Aug

In ancient Israel, on the Day of Atonement, the High Priest took two goats. One of these goats he sacrificed to the Lord, and the other he laid hands upon–symbolizing the affixing of sins to the goat–before symbolically sending it away into the wilderness to represent God’s removal of sin from the people. This, as you may have surmised, is where our term “scapegoat” comes from, meaning one who is blamed for the sins of others.

As implementation of the Affordable Care Act continues, it seems that “ObamaCare” is the perfect scapegoat for the health care system. Initially, the debate over health reform centered on the hypothetical scenarios that might occur if Congress did or did not pass the legislation. Of course, none of us has the prescience to forecast with any certainty what will happen, and the wisest of us in the world of health policy and health services research are quick to acknowledge our limited foresight.

I don’t find this particularly concerning. If the ACA works well, then some measure of success shall have been achieved. If the ACA–or parts of it–fail to work as intended, then we go back to the drawing board and fix things. With the certainty that the current state of the health care system was unsustainable, the uncertainty of ACA implementation and its consequences was an entirely necessary risk to take.

What I am much more concerned with, however, is the potential role of ObamaCare as the scapegoat for anything and everything that goes haywire with the health care system–regardless of whether the ACA was actually the driving force behind it. If, for example, insurers want to raise rates, they can do so–within the bounds of the new law–and they can simply pass the buck by blaming ObamaCare. If physicians, many of whom have notoriously refused to accept Medicaid and even some Medicare patients, want to continue this behavior, they can do so and exclaim: “ObamaCare made me do it!” You get the idea.

So, going forward, it will become extremely difficult for the public to know how well the ACA is or isn’t working, because any number of health care payers and providers will be blaming ObamaCare for their own self-interested business practices. And, of course, the political rhetoric will evolve to incorporate this same theme—ObamaCare doesn’t work, because some in the health care industry say it doesn’t. The American people will need to think back to the time before ObamaCare and ask themselves a simple question: Did my insurance company always look out for my best interests and keep rates low before ObamaCare? Of course not. This will be nothing new. It’s just they have a convenient scapegoat to blame it on now.


Posted by on August 26, 2013 in Uncategorized


2 responses to “Blame It On ObamaCare

  1. Joel

    August 26, 2013 at 10:40 am

    Not quite so sure of yourself these days, I see. When I ask myself the question “Did my insurance company always look out for my best interests and keep rates low before ObamaCare?” the answer is “Yes, but it’s not particularly relevant as I am now with a new insurance company and my premiums have nearly doubled.” (As I understand it, HSAs are consumer-smart but ObamaCare-stupid. The high deductible nature of the plans allow for ultra low premiums and an incentive to look after one’s health, but do not meet the 60 percent actuarial equivalency threshold determined by his Majesty. Whoops!)

    Health insurance costs are skyrocketing across the country, especially for younger people, and apparently the best we have to offer here is “ObamaCare is a convenient scapegoat”. You don’t say… Boy, I can’t wait for all of these delayed components to come online and right the ship.

    I must admit I take some perverse pleasure in watching this Exxon Valdez-esque legislation beelining the course I so dismally set for it a few years ago despite your claim that none of us can predict the future. Then I look at my pay-stub and remember that I’m now living in that future.

    I leave you with this:

  2. Ramona

    August 27, 2013 at 6:57 pm

    The ACA never pretended to reverse the cost trend, only to slow the trajectory. Costs are going up because disease burden is going up. Among other factors. As far as your paycheck stub, you were already paying and didn’t realize it, in the form of raises that didn’t happen and so forth. Premiums increasing just made it more visible to you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: